Karen Mason, co-founder and partner at Newmanor Law and a highly experienced commercial property lawyer, explains what childrenswear retailers should check in their leases before a Santa’s grotto or Christmas market arrives in their shopping centre, from blocked frontages and competing stalls to who pays for the festive programme.
For a childrenswear retailer in a shopping centre, a Santa’s grotto down the mall can be the most valuable neighbour of the year. Families arrive in numbers, children are in a festive mood, and parents are often shopping for party outfits and Christmas presents. Seasonal attractions are not always straightforward for the shops around them, however. A queue can block a frontage, a market stall can sell products similar to yours, and the cost of the whole festive programme may appear in your service charge. Knowing what your lease says puts you in a far stronger position to deal with each of these, and to make the most of the season.
Access to your shop
Alongside the unit itself, most shopping centre leases give tenants rights to use the walkways, entrances and loading areas that customers and deliveries depend on. Landlords usually reserve the right to manage the common parts and to hold events in them, so a centre is generally entitled to put up a grotto or host a market. That right normally comes with conditions, though, such as a requirement that the landlord behaves reasonably or keeps every unit accessible. A grotto queue that stretches across a shop entrance every afternoon in December, or a cluster of stalls that hides a shopfront from passing customers, may go beyond what the lease allows.
If you have concerns about the layout, the best time to raise them is before the installation goes in. Centre management teams plan festive events well ahead, and a conversation about queue routes or stall positions in the autumn is far easier than a dispute in mid-December. If problems arise once the event is running, keep a record with dates and photographs, and put your concerns in writing with reference to the relevant lease provisions. Serious and sustained interference with access could amount to a breach of the landlord’s obligations, including the covenant for quiet enjoyment, although legal advice should be taken before relying on that.
Stalls selling similar goods
Christmas markets often include traders selling knitwear, handmade toys, personalised gifts and other products that overlap with a childrenswear range. Whether you can object depends on your lease. Some leases restrict the landlord from allowing competing uses within the centre, while others offer no such protection. If yours does contain a restriction, it is worth checking whether it extends to temporary traders in the common parts and raising any concerns with the landlord before the market opens.
Who pays for the festive programme?
Christmas decorations, grottos and entertainments are commonly paid for through the service charge, and how much of that cost tenants bear depends on how the lease classifies the spending. The leading case is Boots UK Ltd v Trafford Centre Ltd [2008] EWHC 3372 (Ch). The Boots lease made the landlord pay half of the cost of “Promotion” and capped the amount that could be charged for it. Boots maintained that the decorations, the grotto and the centre’s entertainment programme all counted as Promotion, because each was designed to attract shoppers. The High Court disagreed, holding that they were amenities and attractions provided at the centre, not promotion of it. Tenants therefore paid for them in the usual way, with no 50% contribution from the landlord and no cap.
The decision turned on the wording of one lease, but the same approach now appears in the RICS professional standard on service charges in commercial property, whose second edition took effect on 31 December 2025. Under the standard, the cost of seasonal decorations, events, entertainment and attractions counts as spending on amenities, not marketing, and Boots is cited in support. This is important for tenants, because the standard expects marketing and promotion to be jointly funded by landlord and tenants on an equal basis, unless circumstances justify a different approach. Festive attractions sit outside that arrangement, so unless your lease says otherwise, you should not expect the landlord to share the cost. The lease always takes priority over the standard, which is why its service charge provisions and any definition of marketing or promotion, deserve a careful read.
Seeing where the money goes
Christmas markets also bring money into a centre, in the form of licence fees from operators and stallholders. The RICS standard expects budgets and accounts to explain how this kind of commercial income is handled. In broad terms, if tenants have paid for an activity through the service charge, they should see the benefit of the income it generates. If the landlord has paid for it but it uses services tenants fund, the landlord should contribute towards those services. Money earned from promotional activity is directed to the marketing budget. Tenants can reasonably ask how festive income has been treated. The standard also expects landlords to issue service charge budgets at least a month before the service charge year begins, which gives an opportunity to raise questions about the festive programme before the costs are committed.
Taking a pitch of your own
Some retailers take a stall at a centre’s Christmas market, or a temporary pop-up unit, to reach seasonal shoppers. These arrangements are normally documented as licences, which give fewer rights than a lease. A licence will typically allow the centre to move the stall, require its removal and bring the arrangement to an end on a set date, and the agreement will deal with opening times, stock deliveries, electricity and clearing the pitch at the end. It deserves the same care as a lease, with particular attention to the fee, any extra charges for services and what happens if the market is cancelled or relocated.
Centres typically require operators to carry public liability insurance and to give an indemnity against claims arising from their stall. Check that your own insurance covers trading away from your main premises. Fire safety is a shared responsibility, too. Under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, those with a degree of control over premises have duties in relation to them and must cooperate with others who share those duties, so stallholders should expect to work within the centre’s fire safety arrangements.
Events in your own shop
Some childrenswear retailers run their own festive events, from Santa visits to craft sessions. Within your own unit, you will be the occupier, with responsibility for visitors’ safety under the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957, so think about crowd numbers, trip hazards and the extra stock and decorations that come with a busy event. Where staff or performers will be working closely with children, safeguarding procedures and appropriate background checks matter just as much as they do for a centre grotto. Check your lease as well, as it may require the landlord’s consent for activity that spills into the shopping centre, such as queues, promotional displays or costumed characters outside the unit.
Planning for the season
Festive attractions bring families into centres at exactly the time childrenswear retailers most want to see them. Reading the lease before the season starts, talking to centre management early and keeping an eye on how the festive programme is charged help to make sure the benefits are not outweighed by disruption or unexpected costs.